26. Capital and Social Isms

Capital and Social Isms
Bob Komives
::

Civilizations have disappeared almost overnight when a governmental structure collapsed into the hands of people who could not or would not hold and propagate the communal knowledge nurtured by the government. The overthrow may have been justified by the abuses inflicted by those in power. Unfortunately, knowledge stored (possibly hoarded) by the abusers often got lost to future generations.

When a species or ecosystem disappears, an organ of the biosphere dies; wealth disappears. The biosphere no longer knows how to do some things that it had known. Wealth also disappears when a flourishing society dies.

Societies that we choose to call "primitive" survived with little change in technology or in their systems of government. Across the breadth of the species, however, somewhat unstable groups, "advanced" societies, experiment with ways to organize family, to invest group wealth, and to govern. Using our blessed curses, imperfect mind and imperfect reproduction, they extend evolution out of our bodies into society, to our family and government, to our social-isms and our capital-isms.

Ism-Capitál
Ism-Commún
Ism-Sociál

Planned Economy
Marketplace
Private Enterprise
Free Enterprise
Government Enterprise

How can I speak or write
these terms that have
economic meanings
political overtones
historic undercurrents
redundant redundancies
stark contrasts
subtle distinctions, and
apparent similarities?

I want two of them to stand for all,
to enter the ring, and then
to do battle.

At the edge of the ring paces Marketplace with
free enterprise in her soul
capitalism in her limbs, and
private enterprise in her brain.

In the center of the ring
revolves Socialism with
communism for his soul,
government enterprise
for his body, and
planned economy in his mind.

They spar but seem stuck in their zones.

They jab,
but their gloves barely clash
in the large space between.
(or do they exchange something
that I cannot see?)

She lunges to the center.
He feints and dances to the edge,
barely brushing
as they pass each other by.

Now, she occupies the center
while he patrols the edge.
But, somehow,
in making their moves
they have quick-changed costumes.

She now revolves
in the cloak of socialism
He, an equal transvestite,
paces in the dress of marketplace.
I don't need X-ray vision to see
that they have also interchanged their
bodies
minds
limbs, and
souls.

Apparently, some such parts
work well only at the edge
while others work well only at the center.

I had hoped to see a fight in the ring.

I moved ever higher and farther away in the arena
only to see it filled with rings of many sizes and shapes -the edge of each one sharing the ropes of several others.

Each had its chief of the center
and one or more others
holding forth along the ropes,
where activity ebbed and flowed,
sometimes frantically.

What folly,
to think I could put both transvestites
into the same clothing.
Tragic were the fates of many rings
that did remove marketplace
from their edges,
as peaceful sport erupted into
thievery or war,
or disrupted into
wall or crevasse.

Extinct are the rings
that poisoned their communal centers-
their centerless edges
(having lost all definition)
rewoven with indifference into
the
ropes
of
other
rings.

Equal Transvestites

I find it difficult to write about our "isms": capitalism and socialism. Political and religious groups of divergent persuasions have usurped and shaded the key vocabulary. A simple sentence gets translated by the reader into his own language, which may or may not coincide with my own. True to some degree of all communication, I think the reader-as-writer difficulty is a serious problem when exploring marketplace and socialism, or capitalism and communism. I believe that part of the reason why these words have become burdened with emotion-filled connotation is that the economic definitions are themselves inaccurate.

I choose to discuss marketplace and socialism. "Marketplace," as I use it, includes the general concepts of capitalism, free enterprise, private enterprise, and other near synonyms. Of the choices, "marketplace" says the most and carries the least emotional baggage. For the other half of the discussion I choose "socialism." I use socialism to include communism, planned economy, government enterprise, and several other terms that express communal activity. However, the choice is not easy, so I use a mixture. "Community" and "society" are equally good words. I prefer the "common" and "communal" from "communism" to the "social of socialism," but I prefer the economic meaning of "socialize" over "communize."

:: Bob Komives, Fort Collins © 2006 :: Plum Local IV :: 26. Capital and Social Isms ::
With attribution these words may be freely shared, but permission
is required if quoted in an item for sale or rent

::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::